When Raising Money Feels Like Lucy and the Football: Tempering Expectations with Investors and Publishers

May 23, 2025 | Blog

How Game Developers Can Navigate Funding Setbacks, Build Strong Pitches, and Sustain Hope with Investors and Publishers

In the video game industry, securing funding can sometimes feel like that infamous Peanuts gag: Lucy holds the football, promising to let you kick it—only to yank it away at the last second. You sprint up, ready for lift-off, and suddenly the ground vanishes. If you’ve pitched to video game industry investors or negotiated with publishers, you know this sinking feeling well. Understanding how to manage these emotional highs and lows, temper expectations, and maintain momentum is critical for studios of every size.

In this article, we’ll explore why raising money feels like Lucy and the football in our industry context, how to align your hope with realistic outcomes when talking to investors and publishers, and practical actionable steps to craft pitches, build relationships, and keep your dream alive—even when the football keeps disappearing.

The Lucy and the Football Analogy in Game Funding

Charles Schulz’s Peanuts strip features Lucy van Pelt offering Charlie Brown the chance to kick a football, only to snatch it away at the last moment. For game developers, investors and publishers often play Lucy—and their chequebooks are the disappearing football.

Early Promises: You pitch a prototype at a conference. An investor expresses enthusiasm, talks about term sheets, and sets up a follow-up.
Last-Minute Pullback: When due diligence begins, suddenly concerns arise—market risk, team size, IP strength—and the funding vanishes.
Emotional Whiplash: This cycle of hope and disappointment is draining, yet it’s all too common in the video game industry.

Understanding this pattern helps you anticipate potential setbacks and build resilience, so you can bounce back faster when the football slips away

Why Funding Feels So Elusive

1. High Risk, High Expectations

Investors and publishers see thousands of pitches each year. Only a fraction meet their risk-return threshold. The high failure rate of games makes them cautious, leading to last-minute reversals.

2. Information Asymmetry

You know your project’s nuances intimately; they do not. Gaps in data—unproven mechanics, untested markets—trigger new questions, causing them to delay or withdraw.

3. Shifting Priorities

Publishers might love your concept in January but shift focus to live-service or mobile in June. Suddenly, your football isn’t the game they want to hold anymore.

Tempering Expectations: A Balanced Mindset

To avoid constant disappointment, adopt a balanced approach to funding:

Hope with a Plan: Enthusiasm drives action, but hope alone won’t secure a deal. Pair optimism with structured preparation.
Multiple Balls in the Air: Don’t pin your future on a single investor or publisher. Cultivate several opportunities in parallel.
Vet Early and Often: Instead of assuming interest equals commitment, ask direct questions about timelines, budgets, and decision criteria at every stage.

By tempering expectations, you reduce emotional swings and stay focused on productive activities—actionable steps we’ll cover shortly.

Building Credible Pitches That Stick

Great pitches reduce the chances of the football vanishing. Here’s how to craft them:

1. Data-Driven Market Analysis

Actionable Step: Research comparable game launches: platforms, budgets, time to market, and revenue trajectories. Present a concise market map showing where your game fits.
Why It Helps: Investors and publishers want proof that you understand market dynamics, minimizing perceived risk.

2. Clear Prototype Demonstrations

Actionable Step: Develop a vertical slice or playable demo that highlights core mechanics and art style. Incorporate rapid iteration from playtest feedback.
Why It Helps: A hands-on demo conveys confidence in your critical thinking and development pipeline, making the opportunity more tangible.

3. Transparent Financial Modeling

Actionable Step: Provide a three-year financial forecast—budgets, revenue, cash flow—backed by conservative assumptions and sensitivity analyses.
Why It Helps: When spreadsheets are crystal-clear, the metaphorical football looks less like a mirage and more like a real asset.

4. Team and Track Record

Actionable Step: Highlight prior successful projects, relevant experience, and complementary skills. If you lack a veteran, consider adding an industry advisor.
Why It Helps: Investors bet on people, not ideas. A credible team reduces their fear of a last-minute pullback.

Nurturing Relationships with Investors and Publishers

Securing funding isn’t a one-time pitch—it’s the start of an ongoing relationship.

1. Regular, Value-Driven Updates

Actionable Step: Send monthly newsletters detailing milestone achievements, playtest metrics, and budget burn rates.
Why It Helps: Consistent communication builds trust and reduces information asymmetry, making it less likely they’ll yank the football out at a critical moment.

2. Early Alignment on Expectations

Actionable Step: In initial meetings, ask about their preferred update frequency, acceptable burn rate, and key success metrics.
Why It Helps: Clarity up front prevents misunderstandings later, when shifting expectations cause funding to vanish.

3. Invite to Internal Playtests

Actionable Step: Host quarterly in-studio demo days or virtual playtests where backers can experience progress firsthand.
Why It Helps: Engaging investors/publishers in the development process deepens their investment in your success—both emotionally and financially.

Actionable Steps to Keep Hope Alive

Even the most logical leaders need support when funding falls through. Here are practical steps to navigate the emotional toll and maintain momentum:

Step 1: Create a Funding Funnel

Description: Just like a sales funnel, identify stages—lead, pitch, due diligence, term sheet, close.
Action: Track progress in a shared CRM or spreadsheet. Aim to have 3–5 prospects in each stage.
Outcome: Diversified pipeline reduces the pain of a single rejection.

Step 2: Establish an “Investor Playbook”

Description: Document successful pitch templates, key data points, and Q&A responses.
Action: After each meeting, capture feedback and update the playbook.
Outcome: Continuous refinement increases hit rate over time.

Step 3: Build an Emotional Resilience Routine

Description: Funding rejections sting. Develop rituals to decompress—team retrospectives focusing on lessons learned, peer-to-peer support groups, or brief mindfulness sessions.
Action: Allocate 15 minutes post-pitch for personal reflection and team check-ins.
Outcome: A healthier emotional baseline keeps your passion alive for the next opportunity.

Step 4: Leverage Alternative Funding Sources

Description: Don’t rely solely on traditional investors or publishers. Explore crowdfunding, grants, or strategic partnerships.
Action: Research platforms like Kickstarter or government arts grants; shortlist 2–3 viable alternatives.
Outcome: Additional funding channels provide more “footballs” to kick.

When to Hold ‘Em, When to Fold ‘Em

Knowing when to persist and when to pivot is essential:

Persist If: You’ve addressed identified concerns, revised your pitch with new data, and still see warm signals.
Fold If: Multiple backers cite the same core issue (e.g., market size, IP conflicts) despite iterations.
Actionable Strategy: Use a decision matrix evaluating factors like investor interest level, project traction, and runway. If the score falls below a threshold, reallocate resources to alternative paths.

Measuring Your Funding Strategy’s Health

Track these metrics to evaluate and adjust your approach:

Pitch-to-Term Sheet Rate: Number of pitches vs. actual term sheets received.
Time-in-Funnel: Average days from initial outreach to funding decision.
Alternative Channel Contribution: Percentage of budget from non-traditional sources.
Team Morale Index: Quarterly anonymous surveys on confidence in funding prospects.
Pipeline Health Score: Ratio of “hot” prospects (high likelihood) to total prospects.

Deepening Your Investor Conversations

As you progress past initial pitches and into serious negotiations, the dynamics shift. Investors and publishers dig into finer details—your revenue model, team dynamics, and long-term vision. Here’s how to navigate those crucial conversations without expecting Lucy to keep the football held up indefinitely.

1. Negotiation Mindset: Collaboration, Not Confrontation

Actionable Step: Enter negotiations with a “win–win” philosophy. Instead of viewing term sheets as zero-sum, prepare to ask, “How can we structure this deal so both parties feel secure and share upside?”
Outcome: A collaborative tone builds trust. If investors sense you’re fixated on maximizing your cut at their expense, they may yank back support.

2. Clarify Non-Negotiables and Flex Points

Actionable Step: Before each negotiation, list your absolute must-haves (e.g., IP ownership, creative control) versus areas where you can concede (e.g., marketing budget split, milestone schedule).
Outcome: This clarity prevents costly last-minute compromises and shows investors your priorities are rooted in logic and foresight.

3. Use Data to Strengthen Your Position

Actionable Step: Arm yourself with real-time metrics—early access engagement, demo playtimes, pre-order interest—so you negotiate from evidence, not optimism.
Outcome: Demonstrating traction turns abstract pitch promises into concrete momentum, making investors less likely to withdraw at the finish line.

Sustaining Momentum When Deals Stall

Even well-crafted negotiations can stall. Rather than letting your team’s morale fizzle, use these strategies to keep progress alive.

1. Parallel Tracks: Development and Fundraising

Actionable Step: Continue core development sprints (even at reduced scope) while fundraising. Set a small “emergency scope” that requires minimal resources but maintains forward motion.
Outcome: Demonstrates to investors that you can execute under constraints and reduces the feeling of “the project is on hold.”

2. Milestone Barbell: Big Goals, Small Wins

Actionable Step: Structure your roadmap with a mix of ambitious targets (beta launch) and bite-sized achievements (UI polish, mechanics tweaks). Publicize each small win internally and externally.
Outcome: Frequent wins sustain team energy and signal ongoing progress to backers, reducing the temptation to yank funding when timelines slip.

3. Re-Engage and Re-Validate

Actionable Step: If negotiations stall for more than 30 days, reconnect with investors using new data or milestones. Frame the update as a “re-validation check” rather than a desperate plea.
Outcome: Keeps conversations warm and demonstrates your proactive, logical problem solving approach—rather than simply begging for money.

Emotional Resilience: Keeping Hope Alive

Funding cycles can wreak havoc on team morale. Balancing realism with optimism is key to sustaining a healthy studio culture.

1. Normalize the “Pullback”

Actionable Step: At your next all-hands, acknowledge the Peanuts analogy openly. Reinforce that near-misses are industry staples, not personal failures.
Outcome: Sharing the common experience of disappointed expectations reduces shame and fosters solidarity.

2. Institutionalize Reflection Rituals

Actionable Step: After each funding outcome—positive or negative—hold a brief “Reflect & Reset” session. Discuss what went well, lessons learned, and next steps.
Outcome: Converts emotional energy into concrete actionable steps, preventing morale dips from lingering.

3. Celebrate Non-Financial Wins

Actionable Step: Track and highlight achievements unrelated to funding—press features, community growth, prototype breakthroughs.
Outcome: Keeps the team’s spirit high by reminding everyone that success has many dimensions beyond the bank balance.

Alternative Funding Pathways

When publishers or traditional investors keep pulling the football, diversified funding can keep your game moving forward.

1. Crowdfunding Campaigns

Actionable Step: Plan a Kickstarter or Indiegogo with clear rewards tiers, a polished campaign page, and a realistic funding goal. Leverage your existing community to build momentum.
Outcome: Validates market interest directly and brings in capital without ceding equity.

2. Government Grants and Tax Credits

Actionable Step: Research regional grants for digital arts or R&D tax incentives. Prepare concise grant proposals emphasizing innovation and job creation.
Outcome: Non-dilutive funding bolsters budgets and demonstrates institutional support, which can attract private backers.

3. Strategic Partnerships

Actionable Step: Partner with middleware vendors, platform holders, or IP licensors in exchange for reduced licensing fees or co-marketing support.
Outcome: Reduces upfront costs and provides in-kind value that preserves cash runway.

Long-Term Strategies: Setting Yourself Up for Success

For sustainable growth, embed funding resilience into your studio’s strategic plan.

1. Build a Funding Roadmap

Actionable Step: Map out anticipated funding needs against project phases—prototype, production, launch, post-launch support.
Outcome: Clear visibility on when funding is required and which sources align best with each phase reduces last-minute scrambles.

2. Cultivate a Funding Network

Actionable Step: Maintain relationships with 10–15 potential backers—angels, VCs, publishers, grant bodies—through periodic check-ins, invitations to demo days, and personal updates.
Outcome: A warm network means fewer cold calls and more predictable funding dialogues.

3. Institutionalize Pitch Refinement

Actionable Step: After each pitch, document feedback in a shared “Pitch Repository.” Regularly review and update your flagship deck, financial model, and demo based on this cumulative wisdom.
Outcome: Constant refinement leads to higher conversion rates and less painful football pulls.

Measuring Your Studio’s Funding Health

To stay on top of your financial fortitude, track these KPIs regularly:

Funding Conversion Rate: Proposals → term sheets.
Average Pipeline Time: Weeks between pitch and decision.
Diverse Funding Ratio: Percentage of budget from non-traditional sources (crowdfunding, grants).
Runway Months: How many months of operation remain at current burn rate.
Team Sentiment Score: Quarterly surveys on confidence in funding and project viability.

Final Thoughts

In the roller-coaster world of game funding, raising money feels like Lucy and the football far too often. But by tempering expectations, deploying actionable steps—from robust pitch materials and diversified funding funnels to emotional resilience routines—you can keep your studio moving forward, regardless of who holds the football next.

Your next moves:

Audit Your Funding Funnel: Ensure 3–5 active prospects at every stage.
Launch a Small Crowdfunding Test: Validate interest and gather valuable player feedback.
Schedule a “Reflect & Reset” Session: Normalize lessons learned and set fresh targets.

Hold onto hope, lean into logic, and build the resilience that turns every near-miss into a stepping stone toward your game’s success. The football may be slippery—but with the right approach, you’ll keep your eye on the goal.

Thank you for reading this article to the end. I hope it has been informative and helpful. If you’d like to learn more about the topics we covered, I invite you to check out my podcast and my YouTube channel where I delve into these subjects in more depth.

Additionally, I would love to stay in touch and keep you updated on all the latest developments and insights in the world of leadership. That’s why I encourage you to sign up for my newsletter. Not only will you receive regular updates, but as a thank you for joining, I will also send you my free eBook, “5 Heroic Leadership Skills.” This eBook is packed with practical tips and strategies that will help you take your leadership skills to the next level.

So don’t wait! Sign up for my newsletter today and start your journey towards becoming a more effective and inspiring leader. I can’t wait to hear from you.

🎮✨ Join the Press Start Leadership Discord! 🌟💬

Ready to level up your leadership game? 🚀 Join our exclusive Discord channel where we dive into leadership, mindfulness, and all things awesome in the video game industry! 🎯✨ Connect with fellow enthusiasts, share insights, and join our Accountability Club to stay on track and crush your goals together! 💪🔥

Click here to join the adventure: Press Start Leadership Discord

🎮✨Work With Me!🌟🎮

If you’re on the quest to elevate your team’s leadership, production, or game design capabilities, I’m here to assist! Leveraging extensive experience and a strategic approach, I offer personalized audits, bespoke workshops, and leadership retreat facilitation to drive your team toward excellence. My commitment is to provide efficient, reliable, and proven support, ensuring you have the tools and insights needed to thrive. Ready to unlock your team’s full potential and achieve unparalleled success? Don’t hesitate—Press Start on your journey to transformation today! Feel free to reach out directly to discuss how we can tailor a solution to meet your unique needs and goals. Let’s connect and take your team’s performance to the next level!

🔗 www.pressstartleadership.com

📧 contact@pressstartleadership.com

🎮✨ Discover the Mysteries of Play On Words Studios! 🌟🚀

I’m excited to share the incredible projects Play On Words Studios, my indie studio, has been working on! 🎨🕹️ Dive into our creative world and see the games we’re crafting just for you.

Check out our Studio: Play On Words Studios
Wishlist Shadow City Mysteries: Case Files – Rise of the Rat King: Wishlist Now!
Wishlist Shadow City Mysteries: A Clockwork Noir on Steam: Wishlist Now!
Pre-Order for our TTRPG Book: Pre-Order Here!
Join Our Discord: Play On Words Studios Discord

Join us on this amazing journey and be a part of something truly special! 🌠🎉